Please provide a potential valid use of this data in line with the FBIs mission that doesn't imply circumventing due process?
It would be very useful to the FBI to identify whether they're looking at a solo criminal enterprise or a multi-state organization.
I'll gripe about intel community abuses as much as anyone else, but it's a lack of imagination to say there are no valid, privacy-preserving uses for this.
Historically, Google rightly identified PII as the goose that lays golden eggs, and so voluntarily put safeguards in place around it to prevent individual abuses from killing it.
The FBI could do the same. I doubt it'd be effective, given political pressure from threats and constantly changing leadership, but it's technically possible.
Do the police need a search warrant to lookup who owns a property, or leverage the white pages?