Hacker News Reader

Comment by some_random | Hacker News Reader

Wild that we've kinda just let these random companies handle such a vital part of our global infrastructure

Edit: Made this comment when it was thought that the entire TLD was unresponsive. The point still stands IMO but that's the original context.

View on HN

To be fair, it’s not their DNS that is unavailable, it’s just their Whois server. Whois, while it can be considered an essential service, is not meant to be critical infrastructure. Whois is only meant to be accessed manually by humans (which is enforced by rate limits), and the format of its output is completely free-form, i.e. not machine parseable in the general case.

It does mean all registrations, renewals and changes to ~250 TLDs are out of action though.

None of those are done via Whois. If what you say is true, then it must mean that they have taken down more than their Whois service, and have suspended EPP access as well.

You're right of course that Whois isn't involved in those things. Other comments indicate it's scheduled maintenance, which means EPP is down and most registrars have status updates out indicating changes to these TLDs are unavailable.

Which is not that uncommon. Registries undergo maintenance all the time. The only thing that is really impacted is the ability to register new domains and use them immediately.

If they were just going to open it up to the clowns in this absolute hellscape of a for-profit gTLD third-party rent-seeking shitshow anyways, why not just let any domain at any 'TLD' be registered directly with ICANN instead of this waking nightmare where 'Donuts' owns '.hot'?

I mean I guess there's the beaucoup bucks ICANN gets with application and other fees?

But really, you could just say to a ICANN-accredited registrar 'hey, I want cool.beans' and if not taken by someone else, sure why not. Technically it would be possible, no? Just redirect anything not a TLD already to ICANN? We already have the URDP for disputes and it's not like above said clown show prevents someone from buying mygoogle.limo anyways

Reply on news.ycombinator.com