Hacker News Reader

Comment by xwdv | Hacker News Reader

First generation stars are so massive, couldn’t there be vast numbers of planets in habitable zones orbiting one? Seems good for a sci-fi setting with feasible interplanetary travel and trade amongst many different worlds.

View on HN

Unfortunately not. These stars have no elements heavier than hydrogen and helium so you wouldn't be able to create a rocky planet that's habitable. Furthermore their lifetimes are only 3 Myr which is much to short to form a rocky planet and also the explosion from SN if it happens or direct collapse of the star to a black hole would immediately destroy any life.

Ah fuck, there goes that idea then I guess.

Set it in Universe N+1 of a multiverse and mix in a tiny dusting of metals and such from Universe N.

Or maybe it’s a synthetic population III star, made for unknown purposes by a now-vanished civilization. You’re allowed to make up whatever you need to get the story going.

interstellar travel is so pasky, irritating and slow. A civilized culture might well cultivate such systems so that they could have a huge number of worlds in easy range of each other.

Allow them those abilities and you might as well be importing already inhabited worlds from wherever you like, which saves time.

Yea, but science fiction seems cooler when a story uses some plausible setting. In any case, another alternative is just to have a large planet with habitable moons in its orbit. Perhaps the planet itself is dead and too hostile for life, and the residents of the moons travel around it to get to civilizations on other moons.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com