Hacker News Reader

Comment by Nomentatus | Hacker News Reader

Microwaves are highly tuned to the particular frequency that causes water molecules to resonate. But this is just one microwave frequency. You don't have to use that one.

https://www.gi.alaska.edu/news/using-microwaves-see-through-...

View on HN

> this is just one microwave frequency. You don't have to use that one

The atmosphere is almost transparent to long-wavelength microwave [1]. The tradeoff is in power density.

[1] https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/RemoteSensing/rem...

> Microwaves are highly tuned to the particular frequency that causes water molecules to resonate.

That's an urban legend. If it was true, they'd be great rather than "meh" at melting ice, and (I appreciate most don't do this anyway) we wouldn't be able use domestic ovens for glass-working or melting alumina to make synthetic sapphires and rubies.

• https://youtu.be/XojnG2IFfTo

• https://youtu.be/xwEQZw3KPWg

• https://youtu.be/ybcdRQmQcHQ

Good points, but careful of the logic; yes there's a lot of energy being produced and plenty of harmonics etc. None of which says that every material heats equally well, with no passthrough, or that microwave ovens with different frequencies wouldn't be more efficient for other specific materials.

If a material is dense enough (metal being the prime example) it'll block. I've nowhere argued that you could send microwave power through solid walls - whether brick or sapphire economically.

To expand on my semi-sarcasm with a proper question: so there's a microwave frequency that is completely unaffected by atmospherics? In which water, ozone, the rest of the gas mixure and particulates are mostly transparent?

What frequency spectrum is that? And for bonus points: can this project fry commercial planes?

First sentence: not what was said. But note that microwave towers have been in use for mission-critical long-range all-weather point-to-point communication on earth for many, many decades. My late father helped design some of them.

What would the minimum power loss be for thick cloud/hurricane? Dunno.

Those microwave towers are transmitting some number of milliwatts of power though, with super high gain antennas.

Not kilowatts.

As synonymous comms and power delivery may look, they are a different ball game.

This also seems to be the last nail in the coffin for terrestrial radio astronomy, now that you mention it.

> so there's a microwave frequency that is completely unaffected by atmospherics? In which water, ozone, the rest of the gas mixure and particulates are mostly transparent?

Nope. The transparent bands are in the visible spectrum and far infrared(8-14um). Microwaves are mostly uniformly absorbed by water molecules:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_window

Reply on news.ycombinator.com