Hacker News Reader

Comment by dbmkn | Hacker News Reader

Lol one of his tweets aged well, https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1592852796185128961?s=20&t=...

At first I thought paulg must have posted that weeks ago, but no, it's from yesterday. I wouldn't expect such a vote of confidence on Musk after all the data points we've received since he took over the company.

I'm not even sure what paulg's point is. Are people actually claiming they'd do a better job than Musk, or are they simply commenting on the missteps and bizarre behavior. You don't need to have run a successful tech company to know that spending your time as a CEO antagonizing your employees on social media, and then threatening your remaining employees with an ultimatum is not a good idea.

Sheesh. First of all, we already know that because people have already died due to Tesla software not working right.

And second of all, he thinks Twitter can’t lead to deaths? Let’s say the Iranian government was given unfettered access to DMs and metadata for all Iranian citizens with an account. Not hard to imagine scenarios that end in death.

What's really weird is that he even pushes Musk's conspiracy theory that leftist activist groups are the reason advertisers are jumping off: https://mobile.twitter.com/paulg/status/1593297818420236288

It was a nice r/agedlikemilk candidate but they now have a no Musk rule (https://www.reddit.com/r/agedlikemilk/comments/yqclex/rule_1...)

It's remarkable that someone who's never run Twitter thinks he knows how to run Twitter better than the people who run Twitter.

"This Tweet is unavailable" - what did it (roughly) say?

> It's remarkable how many people who've never run any kind of company think they know how to run a tech company better than someone who's run Tesla and SpaceX.

Then the next tweet says

> In both those companies, people die if the software doesn't work right. Do you really think he's not up to managing a social network?

Thanks!

I was able to view it in Incognito. Why- I don't know, it's been happening with many linked tweets lately as well.

Huh? You have no evidence either way yet.

Well we know that after an ultimatum, enough employees quit that Musk is now asking some of them to come back. The number of employees leaving is also so high, that they're shutting down access to offices. There's also been reports of features like 2FA not working anymore after the first round of layoffs.

Not exactly the results I'd expect from someone who really knows how to run a company.

If one of Musk's middle managers had messed up this badly, Musk would have fired them already. But Elon deserves the continued benefit of the doubt for some reason.

All that you've mentioned may or may not matter eventually but it's not any sort of evidence of how Twitter did. The only things that matter are revenue, expenses, and growth. This tweet was made two days ago and nothing has happened since to provide any sort of evidence of how these actually important factors will unfold. To say that this tweet has "aged badly" is just nonsense.

> The only things that matter are revenue, expenses, and growth.

So... not the general operability of the service?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com