Hacker News Reader

Comment by alessmar | Hacker News Reader

I would like to suggest https://typesense.org/ It has some features that makes it a better choice than Meilisearch

Can you elaborate on said features?

I migrated from typesense to Meilisearch on a project after I found it had much better search accuracy. I can't exactly explain why, but overall Meilisearch results feel more relevant by default.

There are actually benchmarks that allow measuring search relevancy objectively, e.g. BEIR[1]. Manticore Search team did an effort to make a PR to include it to the list. The results are here [2]. Unfortunately the BEIR team seems to be too busy to review a whole pile of PRs including about Vespa. Nevertheless it would be nice to have both Meilisearch and Typesense there too since it's interesting what performance those non-tf-idf based search engines would show compared to BM25-based and vector search engines.

[1] https://github.com/beir-cellar/beir [2] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_ZyYkPJ_K0st9FJBrjbZ...

I work on Typesense. Mind if I ask which version of Typesense and Meilisearch you tried this on? And if this was on some public dataset I can use?

I’d love to take a closer look.

Hey jabo,

I migrated in April 2021 (latest version of typesense & meilisearch at that time).

I don't have a public dataset has it was a fairly large ecommerce catalog with close to ~500k entries. And again, it was just my own perception which is hard to define. I just found that Typesense was a bit off compared to Meilisearch on search accuracy, and of course could totally be different today with a more recent release.

Got it, thank you for sharing that. Typesense was at v0.19.0 around that time. Two prominent issues we had in that version were how we handled matches across multiple fields and how we handled "keyword stuffing".

We're now at v0.24.rc, and we've iterated quite a lot on improving relevancy since then, as more users shared their datasets with us and gave us feedback over the last 1.5 years.

If you get a chance to try out Typesense again in the future, I'd love to hear how relevance feels with the latest version, out of the box for your dataset.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com