Hacker News Reader

Comment by sarchertech | Hacker News Reader

It’s intuitive to any user who has used a web form anytime for the last 2 decades.

Breaking default browser behavior because you find it unintuitive is generally a bad idea.

Now if you’re dealing with something that isn’t really a web form—as in you’re overloading input fields for some interactive non form like behavior—then I can see it.

In my case, if the person had some well thought out reason for doing it, I might let it slide. But the vast majority of times I’ve seen it, it’s because the person doesn’t even know how to use forms. Not understanding the underlying technology at at least a very basic level is a strike against you in my book.

View on HN

fwiw, in my industry, I should not assume anything about technical literacy. We’ve had honest debates over whether we can even rely on people to have an email address.

Again, it’s not that I disagree with most of your premise, but in fact, as the comments (not just mine) show - people have issues with submitting too early, so it can be a good decision to break that depending on context. Fewer errors. Which is why I brought up how the problem is presented to the candidate. You might be filtering out people based on something less universally accepted and understood than you think.

Web forms have a default behavior. It doesn’t matter whether you accept it, you should understand it.

If you accidentally break it because you don’t understand it, that’s a strike against you in my book. If you consciously break it for a good reason and can coherently defend that reason, that’s a different story.

You can always find an outlier who is new to something, but you'd have to show that it's more than a majority of the users to motivate changing the default. Otherwise it's obviously more unintuitive.

At least you'd have to get a sample big enough to make a statistically significant conclusion.

And the burden of proof is on you, because you are changing the default, not the other way around.

Think of any other products, they all have established default behaviours, yet it's also very easy to find someone who's never used a product before and finds it "unintuitive".

And intuitiveness is only one part of usability anyway.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com