Hacker News Reader

Comment by causality0 | Hacker News Reader

This seems a little like an orphan statistic writ large without information about similar processes in other countries. How does it compare to an American author who "isn't a known quantity" in Mexico getting published in Mexico? A Canadian author getting published in Japan?

View on HN

I believe that the English (American) situation is quite bad comparatively. I've seen complaints that Stanislav Lem is still translated to English in very spotty fashion, and quality of translations is mediocre.

The Witcher has finished airing the 2nd season but I wonder if there's a proper translation of original book series into English.

On the other hand, English beats any other language by the amount of original content by an order of magnitude.

What do you mean by "amount of original content": English has lots of native speakers and is the official language of many countries, and I admit the amount of stuff we publish in French is smaller (albeit the quality or focus is very different and I cant find some angles of analysis in English that are trivial in French), I can't believe the quantity of Chinese output would be lower for instance: it's not the same quality and doesnt focus on the same subjects, but it's a lot of people talking and writing about lots of stuff, for a lot longer, no?

I can't believe the quantity of Chinese output would be lower for instance: it's not the same quality and doesnt focus on the same subjects, but it's a lot of people talking and writing about lots of stuff, for a lot longer, no?

You forget how impoverished the vast majority of Chinese speakers have been for the history of the printed word. The US by itself still publishes more original works every year than China, though it's a shrinking gap.

Michael Kandel’s translations of Stanislaw Lem are excellent.

This is something cultural sociologists study. See for instance https://www.thomasfranssen.net/sociology-of-culture though I'm sure there are more recent examples as well.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com