FWIW, after looking into this a bit, it seems to me like that issue is only about as harsh as is warranted, calling someone out for pulling a fast one on their users.

Certainly, I would be shocked if anyone considered Karl Fogel to be some kind of asshole, and yet he can be found in the comments not only defending the premise but also defending the issue's anger.

> I realize that @ddevault's reaction may seems strong, but that's because what you are doing innocently is a tactic that many others have done maliciously. Even if your intent was not malicious, the effect is the same: you are confusing the marketplace needlessly. A bunch of people will get home, open up the bottle, and be surprised to discover lemonade when they very clearly bought "milk".