Comment by agentultra | Hacker News Reader

Comment by agentultra | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Not only is the idea itself not unique; other hackers have been working on this for at least a decade with little practical success. It's hard enough covering a city with wifi let alone connecting a mesh network over the air.

Rushkoff and others think it's just a matter of time... I remain skeptical.

How many of the groups members have worked in telecommunications and understand how antennae work, how signal broadcasting and processing works, how OTA protocols are implemented, etc?

You can't build the kind of robustness that we enjoy today out of commodity hardware. If you want a decentralized darknet, you'll probably have to dust off that 56k modem and get used to using fidonet again.

You can't build the kind of robustness that we enjoy today out of commodity hardware.

And that's not needed either. The purpose is communicating with each other in cases that the government brought down or is heavily filtering the internet (like happens in Egypt, Libia, etc), or in case of a disaster. It doesn't have to be as fast, or robust as the internet. 56k is plenty enough if you just want to send messages or small photos.

And in places no internet connectivity exists at all, it's better than nothing. We're just very, very spoiled.

Amen.

Perhaps it's worth considering that if a new network is extremely slow compared to the present "expensive name brand hardware"-powered internet then it might not attract as much attention from the "streaming premium content" crowd. They might just leave it alone.

Who knows, by building such a network you might in the process prove that there's more value to an internet than simply as a new channel over which to sell branded entertainment and disseminate advertising. You might also show just how much can be done over a 56k link with a little creativity.

In my condo, I can see between 15 and 20 other wifi routers belonging to my neighbors. Every single one of them is password protected. I doubt any of them are talking to one another.

Surely there is room for improvement here?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com