Hacker News Reader

I highly doubt that’s even theoretically possible, given the vast range of variety and quality of music created by humans.

View on HN

Feel like people would have said the same with images 6 months ago tbh. (I mean sure, you could get a fake photograph of a person, but the text control that clip has unlocked is just wild…)

I’m not sure I get your argument. I’m saying that it’s impossible to distinguish between machine written music and human written music.

You could maybe make the argument for distinguishing between a human and a machine playing a piece of music.

But if I write a song that just goes A, D, C, G on a loop (plenty of songs like that), how would you determine that a machine song that goes A, D, G, C is not human written?

My bad, I misunderstood you! I agree with you.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com