Yeah, I meant the goal was good, even if the current implementations didn't work out as expected (at least, as far as I know). But if not the token economy, what other advantage can new entrants offer to compete with the network effects of larger companies?

The goal wasn't just to replace the existing winners with others, but to do so in a way that ensured the gains of the enterprise would be more equally shared with the community. If the token economy can't do this, might there be another way? Or should we declare this a utopia and give up trying?

There should be SOME way to get a win-win from the situation. Some way to disincentivize specultation somehow while still retaining the beneficial effects of tokens??