Hacker News Reader

Comment by My90thaccount | Hacker News Reader

Tailwind means making your HTML non-semantic, usually backed by JavaScript. This has created an arms race where parsers such as screen readers need to do ever-evolving heuristics to provide a reader mode. The code usually cannot be modified or even viewed in a readable form by users. Of all things, it's not user-centric.

You're going to tell me next that you have a JSON interface instead. But that's a site-specific API that's designed for vendor lock-in. You're going to find that doesn't work and need to create a universal format. And now you have completely recreated the problem HTML was intended to solve originally.

All of this wasted effort that web Devs do doesn't come from nowhere. The people with slow browsers or accessibility needs are absorbing your productivity gains 1:1.

View on HN

I'm sorry but this doesn't make any sense at all, what on earth are you talking about? I'm all for constructive criticism, even if it's harsh, but this makes it sound like you've literally never read anything about Tailwind at all.

First, Tailwind has literally no opinion on whether your html is semantic or not. Second, it isn't "backed by javascript", that's nonsense and is just self-evidently not true. Third, "people with slow browsers" benefit because the CSS footprint is smaller. Fourth, the quality of the site improves with Tailwind because developers can spend their unused energy on other enhancements.

Why get on this thread and spew a bunch of bullshit? What's the point dude.

The JS part is just clean up the final result result of classes.

From what I've seen online using Tailwind over other frameworks like Styled Components, gives +5x speed ups. So it is not wasted effort.

> The code usually cannot be modified or even viewed in a readable form by users.

That's right, most of the time it is even minified. It' is not meant to be read by humans but by the browser. Poor accessibility is is a result of it not being prioritized designing/development of a product.

Semantic web is a lie. HTML and CSS is not expressive enough in itself to pull that off - you are guaranteed to put many many divs purely for stylistic reason all around your website. Also, as mentioned there is nothing in tailwind requiring only divs, you can use any semantic tag you want, and the whole page can be completely static without an ounce of js..

At least know the topic you criticize.

Looking forward to the takes on your 91st account.

The semantic web feels like yet more yak shaving. Focus on adding value to people.

I know this cuz I was a big ra ra cheerleader for the semantic web 15 years ago.

But then I found it made no bloody difference in actually helping people.

I’d much prefer if we all spent our energy building better, smarter screen readers.

Pretty sure you haven’t really looked at Tailwind.

It’s as semantic as you make it. And it works without JS.

class names have no bearing on semantics

Reply on news.ycombinator.com