Hacker News Reader

Gotta say that I don't get it either. They've basically just added yet-another-HTML-templating system into the mix. Question not answered: "For the love of all that is holy, why?"

PHP is an HTML templating system. Tacking on yet another one strikes me as more than a little pointless.

View on HN

"All the HTML is in one place and contains as little code as possible.

One place for code that interacts with data.

One place for code that processes requests and responses.

One place for all the URL regexes.

And all these places are predictable."

So, when you have a problem with the system, then to find the bug you have to look in three or four places instead of one.

By that reasoning, we should just code a whole site in a single PHP page that handles both the backend processing and the display layer and generation of HTML.

It's not about decreasing the number of files (to look into to find bugs), it's about organizing the code into logical pieces that are more manageable.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com