Comment by PragmaticPulp | Hacker News Reader

Comment by PragmaticPulp | Hacker News Reader

If you want parts, outsource the manufacturing.

If you want a new, expensive hobby, look into CNC machining. Don’t expect cheap parts, though.

> I am willing to go into the mid 4 figures for a good product(s) that can help me with both bar furniture trim, aluminum fittings, and laser engraving.

Mid 4 figures is about where you’d end up with an entry level 3-axis CNC, workholding accessories, tooling, and all of the other accessories you’ll need to set up the machine and cut aluminum correctly.

That budget is way too low for 4-axis and laser engraving.

I’d outsource the parts and start with a small $3-6K hobby CNC from a known brand (Bantam or PocketNC for example). Learn the basics of machining, CAM, workholding, and other basics on small parts on a small machine, then decide if you want to go bigger.

> and it's tough to wade through the many, many hours of semi-honest use/reviews when I have the day job and fam.

If you don’t even have time to research and learn the basics, you definitely won’t have time to learn how to properly operate a machine and CAD/CAM. I think you’re underestimating the work that goes into even basic CNC machining.

Thanks - that sounds like the General Aviation adage "If you want to build; build. If you want to fly; buy".

However, so much of the work seems to be building experience in the software and getting good at speccing the parts.

How do you get good at even ordering a part so you don't waste tons of time and money?

>If you want parts, outsource the manufacturing. >If you want a new, expensive hobby, look into CNC machining. Don’t expect cheap parts, though.

This 1000%.

If you’re at the point that you think you need custom machines parts for a brewery, then you probably need an interior designer (if these are aesthetic) or a brewing consultant (if these a functional).

I’m all for hobby cnc’ing! I have a probotix and LOVE it! But until you are a “machinist” don’t count on cnc being more than a hobby, not critical path.

> If you don’t even have time to research and learn the basics, you definitely won’t have time to learn how to properly operate a machine and CAD/CAM. I think you’re underestimating the work that goes into even basic CNC machining.

Yup. Time is money. If this is a commercial enterprise, get a professional solution. If this is a hobby project, explore your hobby any way that is interesting to you.

Also, I’ve never seen a brewery with a cnc machine. There is likely a business reason for this.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com