Hacker News Reader

Comment by jimmaswell | Hacker News Reader

Are you serious? It's a very simple thread-based design. Threads are separated by approptiate dividers or whitespace or indentation. I don't get it.

View on HN

The Twitter UI is a mess.

It’s infuriating me to even try to explain the problem to someone who doesn’t see it.

For example, can you explain to me - without going to try it out first - where exactly to tap (on a phone) to view the comments on a picture post in your home feed?

It's messy but as a whole it's not that complicated because the basic model is simple. There's one thing - tweets - and various ways they are listed or threaded.

Can’t you just tap the post (not the picture , but the post).

What do you mean by the “post”? The picture is the post..

The post is a rectangle that spans the width of the column, which contains the picture, and any text commenting on the picture, and the author's name/avatar, etc. It's got a divider above and below to indicate the boundary, and it (at least used to) lights up when you hover the cursor over it.

I do find this annoying now that I recall, but it's the same way to go to a thread here, the timestamp.

This is only in some specific case too - now that I look again, it's simply tapping the post in most all cases. The annoyance I remembered was that tapping the comments icon with the number by it just opens a view to add a comment, not see them.

I also find Twitter nearly impossible to follow. The threaded model is difficult to build a mental model around, you must click/tap endlessly to read a whole thread, I see error messages daily that are incorrect ("this tweet has been deleted" when it has not, or "offline" notices when it is not, etc), significant confusion on tweet metrics (reply count is sometimes visible, sometimes not?), etc. I could go on forever about my issues with it.

Been on since 2009, follow/followed by a few hundred people, use reddit since 2006, blahblah. Reddit isn't great either but I find it a lot less confusing to read on a day-to-day basis. At least old reddit...new reddit is quite confusing IMO in many of the same ways twitter is.

If I had to guess I would vote with other commenters here who are saying that the UX is likely on purpose, and has been built with metrics in mind and not user comprehension.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com