Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by giantg2 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

giantg2·

"...MIT hasn’t offered me any financial aid."

"... Z has offered me what essentially amounts to a full-ride scholarship."

I would go to Z. Free college? Why not.

View on HN

"Free college? Why not."

"Why not." suggests why this can be a very bad attitude trap, you don't value so much what you don't sweat for. If the OP attends MIT he'll sweat more than he would at Z for academics and money, and that will likely make a profound difference in the person he becomes by graduation.

Maybe it will make a difference, maybe not. But the large debt will certainly have a negative impact on his post grad life. You might also be too worried about money to focus on the academics.

What profound differences do you see occurring?

> What profound differences do you see occurring?

You believe "the large debt will certainly have a negative impact on his post grad life." and you don't see that as a forging a profound different in the person he becomes?

Possibly not. Just because it's a negative impact doesn't mean the person makes a change.

Then I submit it's not very negative, it's a part of normal American life, except it's a true investment not so subject to depreciation like a vehicle which is consumption unless it's a means to the end of earning money, or a house which is also consumption with a lot of assumptions it might turn out to be a worthwhile investment.

The same assumption exists for college degrees. Just because you get one doesn't mean you will make money with it, or even that you are better off than if you hadn't gone.

"Then I submit it's not very negative,"

How do you get that from my comment? Just because something is negative doesn't mean someone will change.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com