I'll admit, I'm very fond of PocketCasts, so it'll take rather a lot to get me to switch. But tipping is a feature I'd consider it for.
All told with its various speedup features, I download about 30 hours of podcasts a week, but I probably spend half of that actually listening. (At least some of that is ditching episodes I find dull, but not many.)
Other than that I really am just used to my "workflow". New stuff gets downloaded and added to a queue. I imagine most podcast apps have something like that, but this one has a nice feature set for managing it all.
Thanks for asking. Good luck on your project!