Hacker News Reader

Comment by boboche | Hacker News Reader

Still got mine, freshly recapped. Long live right to repair, teaching kids about retro glory and how stuff actually works at the hardware layer will make sure such iconic pieces of computing will never reach the landfill.

…now if only there could be actual selling 8520 CIA replacement chips/fpga replacement being manufactured AND sold instead of destroying old motherboards…

View on HN

8520's can still be gotten NOS from Analogic and probably a few other places but there are also a couple of projects in progress at the moment to replace the CIA's

https://github.com/niklasekstrom/cia-verilog

https://github.com/bwack/VHDL6526 (6526 and 8520 differ only in their TOD clocks so it should be simple for this to support both kinds)

Lots of CIAs out there are resold broken. The FPGAs are the best option since they wouldn’t break all over again… saw those 2 projects but one is incomplete and the other is not really “fully” tested. There’s that page since a while too but no updates. https://1nt3r.net/j-cia/

Since these were made probably with 100nm+ process, Cost of making them shouldn’t be an issue vs. potential sales, (maybe after the chip shortage ease) since whoever owns the amiga patents are not doing anything better than the last multiple owners since commodore… my money would be on fpgas even if denatures the machine a bit.

I don't know anything about chip design and manufacturing, so I might be way off, but could you just send working Commodore chips to China, and have someone make a clone. It seems like replicating 25+ year old chip technology should be easy enough, or are there simply no plants left that can create compatible chips?

At this point, I’d presume it’s much cheaper to get an FPGA to emulate at the hardware level the chips than it is to order 10,000 new chips in an old fab from wherever.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com