> If God really cared, we would be living in a utopia, free of suffering.

The Christian position is that God made a utopia. The world we are currently living is is abnormal - it has changed.

Well, who changed it? God? No, man did.

But if God really cared, wouldn't He have undone it? He could. The price would be that what we choose and what we do has no effect. That meaninglessness is a pretty high price for utopia.

But does He actually care enough to do anything? Yes. His "fixing" process involved His Son dying on the cross.

That's the Christian position. You may disagree with it. But "If God really cared, we would be living in a utopia, free of suffering" (and therefore either God doesn't exist or He doesn't care) is not the only consistent view of our present situation.