I would also read ivmmeta's response [0] and his reply [1] .
At first I walked away fairly confident at what I had read. Later when I came across the responses, things got more uncertain. The example which quickly comes to mind is that most if not all the prophylaxis studies were not reviewed in Scott's analysis.
[1] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/higlights-from-the-com...