There appears to be a denial of components of this from senior AWS figures, not a blanket denial but I think some of the statements could be a potential overreach.
There appears to be a denial of components of this from senior AWS figures, not a blanket denial but I think some of the statements could be a potential overreach.
An irresponsible researcher will either say "I'm gonna publish because I think it's high impact" and not give a date (and then often publishing with no notice on a Friday afternoon) or won't even provide notice.
It's often impossible to know which type of actor you're dealing with until it's too late. I've even had people claim they won't publish until X date and then publish early. You can't just provide public notice or you'll both piss off the researcher and run the risk of accidentally giving the impression a low impact bug is actually high impact.
Not saying that it’s a certainty it’s not, but if you make such a claim, you should better have some evidence to back it up.
More detail from Colm here.