Hacker News Reader

Comment by nitrogen | Hacker News Reader

The physicality that Compiz and wobbly windows brought to the desktop was a huge boon to my productivity. Everything was low latency, high framerate, and just felt real. I could rotate my virtual desktops around and they felt like actual spatial locations for organization. I could drag windows and they felt like quasi-tangible objects, not just abstract rigid platonic rectangles.

It was far more than just a gimmick, and I really miss the effects today.

View on HN

I have to say the same. It makes the computer "feel" better.

It reminds me of discussions around Mac vs PC in the early days. The experience of using a Mac was more "fluid" than Windows. The Mac would draw windows faster, move the mouse faster (as in more refreshes of the cursor position per second) and that made it more comfortable to use. At the same time I also used Sun and SGI boxes regularly and the stark difference between the jerky mouse movement of the Sun and the fluid, Mac-like, movement of the SGI made the former an inferior experience (even though I liked OpenWindows over SGI's window manager whose name I forgot).

I'd love to have wobbly windows back.

Your comparison of Mac vs PC user experience reminds me of a criticism I read of Java's cross-platform GUI implementation. The critic compared Java GUIs to an episode of Star Trek where aliens had created a facsimile of a room and table of food, but when the Enterprise crew tried to eat the food they gagged on it. It turned out the aliens, working off of visual TV broadcasts, hadn't realized the food was supposed to taste like anything.

Are you sure you're not talking about the feast scene from Galaxy Quest?

>...SGI's window manager whose name I forgot

4Sight!

https://wiki.preterhuman.net/4Sight_Window_System

http://www.vintagecomputers.info/pitechrep.html

http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/sgi/iris4d/007-2001-030_4Sight_...

4Sight Programmer's Guide: GL/DGL Interfaces. NeWS. Window Manager.

If you use KDE wobbly windows are built in to its KWin compositor. :) I forget the exact details of how to get to it since I don't use KDE anymore (long-ish story), but even most of the silly things Compiz did are a configuration checkbox away in KDE.

Yeah, but it just doesn't quite manage to Compiz/Beryl feel. It is difficult to put a finger on but whoever did Compiz wobbly windows had an eye for it that the KDE devs don't.

Using both, I can't imagine getting excited by KDE wobbly windows in the same way that Compiz could get a "wow!" by demoing wobbly windows -> desktop cube.

It was a short, beautiful peak of Linux on the Desktop where a high was reached and then desktops just fell away from it.

It's under Desktop Effects.

It is incredibly ironic that Mac support for high refresh rates is worse than Windows or Linux today. It isn't possible to run an Intel Mac at 4k 144Hz any more, and this is a software issue not a hardware one.

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/253168625

https://wayfire.org — you're welcome :)

Yes, it's a strange effect. I initially dismissed wobbly windows and the desktop cube as very gimmicky bling, but it really did make a huge difference to the feeling of the desktop.

It’s funny how many things go like that. I agree on wobbly windows for floating window managers, though I use a tiling window manager now. In a completely different space, I found similar with expression-orientation in Rust: coming from languages like Python, I initially presumed it to be a gimmick that just let you omit the `return` keyword, but quickly found it was bound up in a better way of thinking about data flow and grasping what’s going on (much like wobbly windows), and now statement-oriented languages are just galling (but I still use JavaScript regularly).

Wobbly windows are still available in KDE Plasma Desktop Environments (I use Kubuntu, but there are many others).

Settings > Workspace Behavior > Desktop Effects > Enable Wobbly Windows

Enjoy :)

I just tried (on most recent versions with Fedora 35). Did not work yet :( Maybe after restart.

Interesting. On my KDE 5.18 (Kubuntu 20.04 LTS) Wobbly Windows worked as soon as I clicked Apply.

You can still use compiz today if you use a modular desktop like MATE or XFCE.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com