Hacker News Reader

Comment by c0nsumer | Hacker News Reader

...then use a different app. There are myriad ways to record rides with no data service; I do it all the time. Most commonly I use Strava or a dedicated Garmin bike computer.

Syncing / uploading then happens once they have signal again. Or in the case of the Garmin I copy the FIT file off by hand when plugging it into my computer.

View on HN

I think that by the time you're at the top of a mountain without cell service, you're already locked in to an app that won't let you record your position.

So your solution for a software problem is buying more hardware. Companies must love you.

I don't think that was the point at all, the point was that if your app doesn't let you record your track without internet connection, then it's on that specific app (and eventually it's on you if you stick with such an app).

There are many apps that let you track your run/hike/ride without internet connection.

You got it; the point is that it's a one-time problem after which a different app should be chosen. There's a ton of things out there which'll record rides offline.

Personally, I think a dedicated bike computer is best, because then the phone's battery is saved for emergency uses instead of recording a ride. For long rides (8-10 hour) phones won't have enough battery to record the whole ride.

Some people like the interface/extra features of an app. I tried going from google maps to open street maps, and came back in 5 minutes flat.

I don't know if companies love him but I know Strava is an android app.

An android app is software.

Not hardware.

What new hardware are you referring to?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com