Hacker News Reader

Comment by ergl | Hacker News Reader

> It's surprising to me that this article, which was mostly about the life of a man on an oil rig, could inspire such discussion about divorce.

It's only surprising if you assume people read the story, instead of simply reacting to the headline. It's against the rules to say, but I'd bet the big majority of commenters never opened the link above.

View on HN

The author of the article (or the editor) also must have thought that it was a key aspect of the article given that it was chosen to be the title.

And there wasn't a great deal else in the article (some discussion of oil rigs, including Piper Alpha, but not much specifics). We never got to find out what the stories written by the person being interviewed were. I actually found it a bit odd, like it was an introduction to a longer article that got cut off just as the main part was starting. In the end, the anecdote involving divorce was the only substantial thing in there. So even if you did read it, that's a fair part to react to.

Agreed, felt I was dropped into a big-oil exposé and then it made a left turn and stopped.

That was exactly the feeling I had. I actually thought it was a very interesting article about the life of an oil rig worker. Suddenly, and in a throwaway fashion, we get a rumor about some unfortunate man and that's all. If this was meant to be an article about divorce, why wasn't there more divorce-related material? If this was supposed to be about oil rigs, why not focus on that and change the title? Very jarring experience all-around.

You can see a note under the text noting that it's a book excerpt: https://bookshop.org/books/sea-state-a-memoir/9780063030831

Ah, thanks, I missed that

Reply on news.ycombinator.com