Comment by jimmygrapes | Hacker News Reader

Comment by jimmygrapes | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

I have noticed the same sense that hundreds or thousands of views or likes or whatever is unfairly compared to those others with the tens of thousands and millions, with one critical exception: forum karma. It seems like when people communicate to each other through text, even a few down votes are often cause for extraordinary negative reaction on the part of the creator. So much so that it's a rule to not complain about it, here.

Assuming I'm not alone in witnessing this, I wonder two things: 1) what makes a forum environment different? and, 2) do people who react poorly to negative karma (or meager positive karma) ALSO expect high engagement IF they create on other platforms?

For example, I present a hypothetical person on reddit with accumulated "high" karma (say, high 8000s). This person also has 10k followers on TikTok, 3 YouTube videos with 6 digit views, and several viral tweets. They get -5 karma on a random reddit post and freak out. What makes the raw number differ between platforms? Is it raw number or a ratio of potential to actual?

(yes I know this is the epitome of a strawman, but I'm basing it off of a cohort of roughly similar real people)

I think you're describing loss aversion.

To me getting a -5 downvoted post roughly feels like the inverse of making a 50 upvoted post. I don't care about either, but yes minus has a bigger emotional impact than positive.

I doubt the number matters so much that it is negative. If you put in a few minutes to write a reasoned, thoughtful and informative reply and the groupmind instantly -50's it for no discernible reason, that's a really good signal that investing time in that community is a poor decision.

Reddit used to have informal rules against downvoting those you disagree with because it lowers the caliber of participants on their forum. I guess they don't enforce it any more.

I used to be affected by downvotes a lot. I understand them on aggressive shitposts, but on comments with facts or comments that I've put a lot of thought in? It just doesn't make sense!

It's like having a group of people think up ideas for something and then you share yours and everyone tells you to shut the fuck up. That sort of feeling.

I never downvote. Either upvote or leave it, it achieves the same thing imo.

Fortunately I learned that any interaction on general social media is absolute garbage and not worth the emotional (and even intellectual/mental) investment.

I'm here because I'm a dumb addict. I am/was on small technical forums because that's where my interest lies and I can share and learn specific knowledge. Sadly it's all moving to Reddit nowadays, where you're one misclick away from drowning in shit.

Downvoting to express disagreement is accepted practice here.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com