Hacker News Reader

Comment by WastingMyTime89 | Hacker News Reader

It’s not an either/or situation. We both need more regulation and harmonisation regarding tax evasion and tax dodging both inside and outside the EU and less regulation when it comes to starting businesses.

View on HN

No we do not. Tax harmonization is being aggressively pushed by certain member states for their own benefit and to the detriment of other, less developed member states.

That’s completely false. The EU budgets itself is extremely favorable to less developed member states even when these states should be excluded from the union like Hungary. The current tax issues favor countries which are already rich like Luxembourg and the Netherlands at the expense of countries which are actually producing values in Europe. It has nothing to do with the eastern countries.

EU cohesion funds and other forms of block-wide handouts are not a substitute for functioning and competitive economies. The ability to compete on taxes is absolutely critical for these small countries to attract business and retain their human capital (which would otherwise just leave for developed western-European countries).

> ability to compete on taxes

To steal from other EU members is no competition it's just unethical. Small countries can live just by cashing a small part of the money that is rightly owned by countries with more population. That needs to be fixed.

Competing for foreign investment is not stealing. What you're implying is that small countries should know their place, not rock the boat too much and above all else, never dare compete with bigger countries...or else. Needless to say, such a stance is antithetical to the very foundations of the European Union. The free movement of capital, labor and goods & services is a whole package - you cannot pick the parts you like and disregard the parts you don't because they're not to your advantage.

That’s a misrepresentation of the situation. Developing EU countries are not currently and can’t compete for foreign investments with the block heavy weights. They have neither the infrastructure nor the human capital to do that. The bigger European countries are the one heavily investing in the developing countries for manufacturing.

Also obviously the EU can put in place any kind of controls it deems necessary on the common market. It’s sovereign in this matter after all and tax dumping is mostly helping foreign-based multinational corporations.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com