Hacker News Reader

Comment by phito | Hacker News Reader

You got me curious, so I tried that app, and I'm getting "Unknown species" for every single one of my plants... I guess no identification is better than bad identification.

View on HN

You need to click on the "Unknown Species" box in order to get a list of suggestions. Probably not the most intuitive, but it avoids auto-assigning IDs without prior review.

Perhaps they are unknown species! Hah, well, sorry my recommendation didn’t come through, I can imagine it performs better on common plants everyone takes pictures of, which is what I’m identifying when I walk around town.

Still, if you post the plants under a more general species other users can identify it mentally, adding to the data set.

It is an important feature. For plants, users will immediately see that the answer is wrong but for many other things (identifying suspects automatically) it might not be as obvious.

As a bonus if the algorithm can tell it can't identify correctly you can use this feedback to teach the algorithm.

A great example of this is the Akinator app. The developers built up a database of answers by getting the users to fill in the missing data, which produced more accurate results and subsequently attracted more users. That feedback loop for apps like this seems like a very effective model. What I find interesting about this is that the value of the product, from a business perspective, comes from the success of the software in enabling that feedback loop, while from the user’s perspective, the value is in the data. But the data is emergent from the feedback algorithm.

Is it perhaps also a difference in intended use? If iNaturalist is for wildlife and uses location heavily, eg identifying tropical houseplants indoors in a different region might not work.

The GPS helps with a “seen nearby” weight, but it shouldn’t exclude anything. Could be a factor of photography, with some plants it’s easier to get a nice canonical leaf shape than others. Taking a wide angle of a potted plant such that the whole plant is in frame might not provide enough detail, so there’s a learning curve in knowing how to photography for the algorithms benefit, kind of like learning how to phrase search queries for better Google results

Could be, I just set location data on it with the original location of the plants, but it still cannot ID them. Granted, they are not very common species.

Are they garden plants?

No, they're carnivorous plants grown in greenhouse.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com