Not being perfect would be acceptable, but at this point it looks like something with the potential of setting back software quality and security [1], with the added bonus of also breaking copyright/licensing.

[1] I understand that everyone should review code before committing, but even if me and my team do it, there's no way all the proprietary and open-source software I use has teams doing the same. That's why I worry for my security.

There are two types of products: the ones that people complain about and the ones that nobody uses or cares about; based on a famous Bjarne Stroustrup quote.

The fact that people post about it, point out flaws, leave GH out of spite, etc. only goes to show how impactful a system like this can be. It's a big deal, which is why people talk about it.

That it's perfect.