Hacker News Reader

So we shouldn't catch criminals then. By that logic, investigations, and evidence gathering for said investigations is not right either.

View on HN

There are very good reasons for evidence obtained by unlawful means to be ignored, even if it would help to catch a criminal.

I never understood why that's the case. Is it not to encourage unlawful activity?

Stealing an example from mr robot, if I break into someone's computer and find evidence that proves they are trafficking underage photos, I don't see why that proof should be ignored , in any circumstances.

Sure, charge me as well with breaking into someone's computer, if you can catch me, but don't dismiss my evidence.

It is to discourage unlawful activity on the part of law enforcement.

Sure, and that's probably best. In my original comment, I specifically mentioned that what the FBI is asking for is reasonable providing there is a warrant, which would imply that they're gathering evidence lawfully.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com