I think you misunderstood my question. I'm asking whether you think the law should let Toyota get away with it.
I’m also saying that our culture absolute swims in regulation and we as fish just get used to it and are quick to reach for it as a hammer, seeing everything as nails. We are so steeped in it, that in many ways _China_ has a freer economy than the US does. I’d urge much caution here.
Whatever the law I would like to be would depends on whether I'm Toyota or I'm the customer.
Which do you think is more fair and better for society as a whole?
as a whole ? I believe there can't be such thing. Fair for one may not be fair for other. 'Better' for one may not be better for other.
It would be better for both to enforce contract law all around. Don’t let either lie or steal and you’ll have a better outcome for all.