Hacker News Reader

Comment by nsajko | Hacker News Reader

Is your argument that Apple shouldn't themselves bear the responsibility of choosing an unsustainable/immoral/illegal business model?

View on HN

unsustainable ? It sustained alright for many years and has brought lots of profit for apple

immoral? Its subjective. I disagree and apple likely don't think its immoral

illegal? isn't that what the trial is for ? to decide whether this is illegal.

And free + ads is a moral business model?

No ones forcing you to buy an iPhone; if this is really bothering you, go to Android or petition Microsoft or Amazon to start up their phone efforts again.

The problem with that is that this isn't just about end-users. Apple is being unfair to developers too, and just leaving iOS isn't a viable choice for them. Apple has a 50% market share in the US, so any American company who cut ties with them would instantly lose half of their customer base, since most people won't buy a new phone over a single app.

You act like it’s the developers fault that they hitched their wagon to apple. They knew going in with eyes wide open what the deal is. They can always leave en masse to Android if they feel the deal is not fair.

Yes, they knew going in how unfair Apple is, but they knew the alternative, being shut out from half of their customers, was worse. And are you really suggesting that all app developers need to form a cartel to level the playing field with Apple? If not, how do you suppose they all leave en masse, rather than some staying behind to steal the market share the others left behind?

I’m glad we agree that they willingly entered a contract, no one forced them.

Yes, I’m suggesting that people leave if they are unhappy with Apple. Go to Google; or maybe MS or Amazon will see how hated apple is and start a new phone division. That’s how markets work.

Companies that have seemed on top and undefeatable before have fallen due to customer unhappiness, and can fall quite quickly, too.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com