There are other reasons that inflation is good too, having to do with sticky wages and recessions. I'm not sure how to work that into the cake analogy though.
The perceived value of each slice relies a lot in the psychology of the public.
It's the job of the central bank to make sure the slices are proportioned properly and the perceived value of each slice of cake is maintained.
We don't have good models for how the economy actually works. Until 2008 most models didn't even have a financial sector. Currently economic models can't accurately predict the velocity of money or even explain changes after the fact very well. We still have no consensus among economists as to what causes recessions.
So this is an experiment but the claims that it is "obviously" going to lead to inflation are flat wrong. We are going to learn a lot from this experiment. If we need to pull back to bring down inflation, we have tools for that.