https://twitter.com/danheld/status/1351235080103096331
It starts off with:
"1/ Bitcoin’s energy consumption is not “wasteful.”
- It is much more efficient than existing financial systems
- No one has the moral authority to tell you what is a good or bad use of energy (ex: watching the Kardashians)
Let's debunk this FUD"
I find this really hard to believe. And it would really depend on what you’re measuring. If we look at transactions per second, the numbers aren’t good for Bitcoin. But really, what we’re talking about here is transactions per Watt of power. I’d love to know what these numbers are, but I can’t imagine it looks good for Bitcoin.
Maybe it looks better if you look at the total value of transactions per Watt (fewer transactions, but at high amounts). But then, Bitcoin starts to look more like a reserve currency where the major transactions are between large clearinghouses instead of a totally decentralized monetary system.
Bitcoin, Ethereum etc. can be spent nearly nowhere except at exchanges because it's a pain in the ass to handle for merchants while I can pay with my Visa in the most countries seamlessly.
And how can it "bank the unbanned" when people need to have not only a smartphone but also a stable internet connection to the networks because if I don't observe the blockchain, I am still reliant on intermediates which are called payment processors in the traditional system that already exist.
Crypto currencies are just unnecessarily speed running financial history. Carried by ancaps and speculation that are only pushing it because legislation didn't catch up, yet.
It's also including households, trains, data centers, etc. Things people actually use to live. Meanwhile with Bitcoin people are just rushing to calculate as much zeros as possible into their hash to append 1 MB of data to a chain.
“No one has the moral authority to tell you what is a good or bad use of energy” followed by “Bitcoin uses less energy than than banking and the military,” implying that these are “bad” uses of energy — and in fact, that’s the entire foundation of the Bitcoin cult! That Bitcoin is better than Fiat, that it’s the righteous currency because of decentralization/etc. When you have God on your side (in this case, Satoshi, someone revered despite having never been revealed as existing...) you can justify anything. Even massive energy waste and pollution.