Hacker News Reader

Comment by pbreit | Hacker News Reader

I suspect the best course of action is to build it so that folks can better evaluate how compelling it is. I also doubt a Vbulletin-based solution is going to fly with this audience.

View on HN

No offense but that's some strange advice. OP would likely have to spend 10-20 hours getting it to a point where it would be usable/impressive. Personally I think it's wise that he asks the community if they are even interested before he spends that sort of time.

Sorry, but the culture here is more of the variety that if you think you have a good idea, you build it and see what people think. Code speaks. You're not going to get terribly actionable feedback here as you would if you had something to show. There's a whole genre of "Show HN" and weekend projects.

That's not exactly true. I'm not new here. Just because there's a bunch of teens and young 20s doing "Show HN" stuff doesn't mean that "Build first, find market second" is the best thing in all situations, does it? Lots of "Show HN" stuff is of the "Hey, I'm learning {new language} and built this to help learn it. What do you think?" variety which doesn't apply here.

The way I see it the guy asked a question hoping to help the community and you are flippantly telling him his question is worthless; that you won't give him "actionable feedback" until he spends 20-30 hours on it. Pshaw.

It's not that it's teens and 20-somethings. It's that it's "Hacker News" and the culture drafts off of pg and Y Combinator. If you think you have a good idea, you build it. I was not being flippant at all. There is an extreme bias towards building in this community. Sorry.

I disagree, respectfully of course. Rather than "build it", I think the culture here is "fail fast". What better way to fail fast than to figure out that you should not waste your time building something because no one cares/needs it?

Correct, I'm looking for people who would take this interesting, and would spend their time on it, as they do on HN.

Also, a side note was I'm also looking for developers/designers who would like to have this as a fun side (paid) job.

>>I also doubt a Vbulletin-based solution is going to fly with this audience.

Webmasterworld uses a traditional forum software like vbulletin and it works quite well. Audience of HN and webmasterworld are not very different by standards.

"Audience of HN and webmasterworld are not very different by standards." cough

vBulletin is very open-based, I have a license that I paid a while back of $200.

I'm looking for others who are interested to take part in this new community board.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com