Most people wouldn’t pay but some would pay a lot, in the form of donations.
I can easily envision a world where Facebook was a nonprofit along the lines of Wikipedia. Ad-free and supported by donations, the site would serve to connect the world (Facebook’s ostensible mission) without resorting to dark patterns or A/B testing for addictive engagement. I think there are plenty of wealthy people out there who would love to support such a site, if it existed.
Technology-wise, such a site could be built today, no problem. I have no idea what to do about the network effects that comprise Facebook’s moat, however.