Hacker News Reader

> when preceding a consonant or a vowel.

When preceding the sound of consonant or a vowel.

This is somewhat tautological, since consonants and vowels are already speech sounds.

No, not really. The word "user" starts with a consonant sound, for example, even though "u" is a written vowel.

From what I have seen, people writing about linguistics do not usually bother specifying this distinction in this context. It is usually implied that an expression like "following a vowel" or "following a consonant" has nothing to do with orthography, but the actual phonetics. The orthography is not really considered a source of truth.

They are sounds as well as groups of letters, but the OP didn't specify, hence my clarification.

Some examples:

* "He has an MBA" because "M" sounds like it starts with a vowel (here: "em").

* "a university" ("you-ni...")

Reply on news.ycombinator.com