Hacker News Reader

Comment by LeoPanthera | Hacker News Reader

Their mistake was keeping the old interface around at all. If they had just killed it off we would have complained about it for a while and then just moved on.

View on HN

Killing off the old interface and forcing users to use the new one is the reason Reddit still exists and Digg effectively does not.

I find it impossible to believe that at all. The new Reddit UI is essentially just a reskin. The Digg "redesign" was an entirely new concept that radically changed the purpose of the site. The two aren't comparable at all.

Come on, are we really going to get this hyperbolic? The amount of people complaining about the interface is a vocal minority.

A very significant percentage of Reddit browses the old interface (I think 20% or 30%). These people are likely to leave and help create another viable competitor.

IF the old interface is replaced by the horrific one that shows like 5 articles I will never visit again.

Maybe we’re just not the target audience for reddit anymore. I’ve spoken to spoken to zoomers who use reddit and their response is that the “new UI” is all they’ve used and they like it because everything is embedded in the same page and scrolls like their twitter/facebook/instagram feed.

That's probably the case.

I only use Reddit from behind Tor, on desktop, so I open a bunch of tabs to amortize the load time, then read them in sequence and close each one as I read it.

If you have fast Internet and a short attention span, and faith in your web browser's back button, maybe that doesn't make sense.

You can configure the view to "classic" or "compact", and it shows the same number or more posts than the old design.

ask Digg how well that worked out...

Digg was flooded with College Humor posts and XKCD comics before the redesign. For some reason, people think the redesign was the reason why people left.

Genuine question: What's wrong with XKCD comics?

A sign that there's nothing good on the site, just people reposting the same stuff, maybe with text macros.

There's 3 new comics per week. It's not like you can sustain a whole website on that.

> It's not like you can sustain a whole website on that.

I don't know, xkcd.com seems to be doing just that.

Nothing, but I go to xkcd.com for that. IMO, the only valid use of reposting xkcd is when the thing you're posting is pertinent to the conversation. Like if somebody's among the lucky 10,000 who hasn't heard of nerdsniping until today.

Considering the new UI regularly takes up literally takes up 100% of my laptop's CPU, it would mean I would have just stopped using Reddit. Last time I tried it I couldn't even scroll without all sorts of yanking.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com