Hacker News Reader

Comment by emodendroket | Hacker News Reader

I mean who's supposed to be the "good guy" then, Apple?

Apple is the “least bad” guy at the moment. They are not “good”. But all the big guys are bad to some extent. (And since you brought them up - Apple’s cloud push is bad, though not remotely as bad as Microsoft’s cloud push)

I am not saying Microsoft is exceptionally bad in any way. I am just saying the “new, good Microsoft” is a mirage. They are as bad as they had ever been, except they have been beaten into submission in some sectors, so they behave in those.

Apple is the worst with their initiative to make their devices irrepairable, monopolistic practices on iOS and extracting value out of their target audience ruthlessly.

Apple does not have a monopoly - Android outsells them significantly in just about every market. Microsoft still has a PC monopoly. That makes a huge difference.

And yes, Apple making their device impossible to repair is evil, but their value extraction is opt-in (buy buying into their ecosystem) because they are not a monopoly.

What we have is an unregulated duopoly and Google and Apple are filling their boots.

The App Store is where they hold a monopoly.

I was referring to the legal concept of monopoly, of which they have non, and Microsoft does (and was in fact, convicted for abusing it, independently in the US and in the EU).

(The kind of monopoly Apple has on the appstore, much like the Sony monopoly on the playstation, and Microsoft on the Xbox, is not AFAIK an antitrust target because non of them command a significant part of a market without alternatives; whereas Windows on a PC was an antitrust target because it does have that hold on a market, AND microsoft abused it to enter other markets).

And Apple is the best (of those companies) when it comes to privacy and not spying on your every single digital move.

It is an open secret that Apple is doing all these privacy things for two reasons: PR and for setting themselves up as the only choice for ads for iOS users (which will soon include Mac). How anyone can just look past this (and that they jumped into NSAs arms and shared everything) baffels the mind. Apple is in no way less evil than Facebook or Google.

They're much less evil than Facebook in my book.

w.r.t google, it seems like Apple is the lesser evil - as far as I (and anyone I know) can tell, if you turn off location tracking, it actually stays off.

But there is definitely no "good guy" among the big player. Right now, Pine64 and Puri.sm are the only not-yet-proven-evil guys around, and they are both minuscule.

The evidence for MS being bad in the post I replied to is them forcing Edge on you. Well, can I uninstall Safari, or install any other browser on iOS that isn't a reskin of Safari? Not so far as I'm aware. The integration is much tighter than what MS offers.

Why does there have to be a "good guy"? Can't there just be a bunch of different bad guys?

If Microsoft is supposed to be exceptionally evil then surely we can see other actors in similar position who aren't as bad.

> Why does there have to be a "good guy"? Can't there just be a bunch of different bad guys?

Narrative tropes demand that there be a protagonist, so one of the bad guys must be cast as an anti-hero, at the very least.

Huh. I just realized that to many of his supporters, Trump is an anti-hero. No wonder pointing out his flaws doesn't work.

The FSF.

IMO decentralization and competition are the only way to get the bad actors to occasionally do good.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com