>This is not what a dialogue looks like

Yes it is. You just don't like it.

The post you're replying to lays out, from their perspective, a list of actions that they believe are self-evidently unjustifiable.

Do you agree with that assessment? Do you believe there's justification to be had? I think most of the real arguments in favor of them have been left unsaid, because they fundamentally contradict a number of modern western paradigms regarding inherent rights and human dignity. But that's not really fatal to the philosophic position; maybe those paradigms are false.