Hacker News Reader

> Trump saying "I WON THIS ELECTION, BY A LOT!" [1] is clearly equivalent to shouting "FIRE".

No, it’s not equivalent at all because it doesn’t present any immediate danger. The reason yelling “fire” is a problem is not because it’s a lie, it’s because it requires immediate and possibly dangerous behavior (evacuate as quickly as possible).

View on HN

There was a bomb threat in Philly yesterday. His speech is dangerous and he should be shut down if it is inciting similar violence and factually false (which it is.) There are armed protestors in Airzona outside of poll counting places:

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-protests-ari...

That is dangerous and is not protected by the first amendment.

You're right that it doesn't present an immediate danger on the order of seconds or minutes in the same way as my analogy.

However, I personally believe that his false speech does present an immediate danger to the public on the order of days or weeks.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com