Not sure what is meant by "S3 has 11 nines of durability". Obviously not an availability number, but what is it?
I'm guessing it's closer to the way that telecom guys work: 1 bit error in 10^12 bits is common for fiber comm.
Looks like they're differentiating between durability ("99.999999999%") and availability ("99.99%").
So it's not uptime that has 11 9s…my mistake. Should have checked the documentation.