Love the breakdown - "scrappiness and drive" at 35%. To me resourcefulness is #1 - I don't care if someone has the experience, I care that they can go out and figure it out on their own.
It frustrates me that our profession seems to have no real career path. It's great that you can hit the ground running, but we do seem to systematically devalue experience. And it DOES matter, though it's obviously not just about years. (I've certainly known plenty of folks who had been doing bad work for decades.) But we don't have any kind of formal mentoring system like you'd see in other professions, and I think we're worse off for it.
Yes, it does seem like the only mainstream profession where having 20 years of real experience means virtually nothing.
IOW, our profession is so shallow that virtually anyone can do your job if they want to.