So... merger of two neutron stars, resulting in a black hole? If we see black hole mergers all the time, why not neutron star mergers?
I guess I'm not sure what all the fuss is about. "Oh neat, we found something in this mass gap" seems reasonable, but the "changes astronomy" headline seems completely unsupported.
What would it even mean for it not to be possible? Two neutron stars of appropriate size collide -- you end up with something. I'm sure the physics are interesting in this range, but I have a hard time understanding how it could just not be possible. (Rare, yes.)