Hacker News Reader

Comment by FridgeSeal | Hacker News Reader

F# is the language I want to like, and would like to use in prod, but it constantly feels like the ignored step-child.

The REPL is great in theory, but trying to import packages is a nightmare every time I try.

Dependencies exist, but they all seem to target wide and inconsistent range of the ecosystem. Want to target dotnetcore 3.1? Good luck have fun: everything you find useful is targeting some combination of standard/framework/core/whatever confusing variant Microsoft decides to come up with this week.

If I somehow convinced my co-workers to adopt a language that wasn't C#, I'd point them Rust or Haskell instead.

View on HN

Most of those package issues also apply to C# particularly as it stabilizes towards .NET 5. However it isn't too bad once you get it; and for most standard use cases it seems to work with the dotnet cli out of the box. Many people seem to be productive with C# so I'm not sure how big of an issue it is other than the small initial learning curve but many package managers have that (IMO Maven is harder yet many people use that in Java space and not too hard once you learn it).

REPL's often have problems with package management in a number of languages as they often have a different build chain from the compiled style apps which have the chance to resolve packages. When doing .NET Core in the past I know Paket can generate these scripts for the REPL to import packages (seen csx/fsx scripts for each package) - but another comment alludes to a more supported way in the future which is good.

Doesn't seem like you have a problem with the language per se; rather the package management story for .NET Core.

I totally agree with your points but the situation seems to be improving. With https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/announcing-f-5-preview... you can import nuget packages in fsx scripts. The dependency situation also seems to grow saner every month.

Nevertheless i would still wait another few month for things to stabilize with .net 5.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com