But once the auto-pilot stuff is done, I'm wide awake and fully productive.
Do you ever crash around 4PM? I find that there are many days where I absolutely need a strong cup of coffee right around then, just to get me through to about 6PM when I perk back up again.
I find I'm typically happiest and most productive when I go to sleep and wake up as I wish. Normally for me this is sleep around 23h or 24h and waking up around 9h-ish. Of course, having to work an 8-hour day in the middle of my 14-15 waking hours only leaves me with 6-7 hours for commuting, cooking, eating, working on side projects, working out and spending time with my fiancee. Unfortunately, I often while away the hours working on side projects to the neglect of the rest of the things I care about. :\ When I do this, I often stay up well past midnight, so I get less sleep. My schedule winds up being something like: sleep from 2am to 7:30am, prep + commute + work + commute until about 6pm, eat and veg with fiancee until about 8pm, then work on side projects until 2am.
That stuff is particularly bad for me, so I'm off it totally. I definitely feel more energetic over the course of the day than I did drinking as much caffeine as I could. Or anything in-between.