The blacklist does not only have to affect me, just throw in the blacklists of my social graph too. These are the people I trust.
Facebook, on the other hand, has developed a system where nearly every user activity creates a new easily processed and meaningful connection between users or out to the web itself. And those connections are probably closer to representations of some kind of trust than "I email that person a lot".
Anyway, I'm not saying the sky is falling for Google, just that search appears to be changing for the first time in awhile.