The bulk, 64% of our water (2018), comes from our groundwater aquifers and in-state rivers (and 3% reclaimed) according to ADWR [1]
Yes, it's still important and I agree we should diversify our economy away from agriculture, but that is not something you can just do immediately especially when the citizens that industry is supporting are under-supported by both the community and the U.S. government as a whole.
I will not blame people immigrating to the U.S. for relying on one of the only jobs they can get to put food on their tables while our government actively tries to persecute and deport them, and our citizens inactively support them. These people need our agricultural industry to live, and until we give them a replacement somehow we are SOL.
You're right that the Colorado River is irrelevant to the issue under discussion here. But the article clearly shows that the aquifers are as big a crisis:
In the late 1990s, during the first few years of what would eventually turn out to be a 19-year-and-counting Arizona drought, only about 15,000 acre-feet of water were estimated to have percolated into the aquifer each year, while 100,000 were being pumped out; as the valley continued to warm throughout the 2000s and 2010s, with rainfall and snowmelt plummeting, estimates for recharge went unrecorded, as annual pumping soared to 200,000 acre feet. Once, it had been possible for ranchers to develop natural springs into watering holes using only a shovel. Now, after watching water levels drop 100 to 300 feet in 35 years, some farmers wondered how long they could go on... In 2017 alone, one farm pumped 22 billion gallons, nearly double the volume of bottled water sold in the United States annually.
Immigrant laborers and immigration are largely a non sequitur. They're cannon fodder in this battle and scarcely mentioned in the article. They have no say in it. Unless you're talking perhaps about Middle Eastern farming corporations. This is a battle between relatively prosperous local small farmers and bigger corporations:
Arizona was particularly attractive to Middle Eastern farmers. A policy of unregulated pumping on the Arabian Peninsula had, in 40 years, drained aquifers that had taken 20,000 years to form, leaving thousands of acres fallow and forcing Saudi Arabia and others to outsource much of their agricultural production. In 2014, a Saudi Arabian-owned company, the Almarai Corporation, bought 10,000 acres in the town of Vicksburg, northwest of Sulphur Springs Valley, planting alfalfa to ship halfway around the world to feed Saudi cattle. Then, a United Arab Emirates farming corporation, Al Dahra, bought several thousand-acre farms along both sides of the Arizona-California border. These purchases were perfectly legal, but many residents felt these newcomers were essentially “exporting water.”
You know where thos leafy greens grow better? Everywhere
It takes less energy to air condition Phoenix during the summer than Minneapolis takes to heat in the winter (temperature gap desired maxes 50F vs 100F). Additionally, the energy it does take is much more amenable to being fulfilled by cheap solar than the cycle required by heating at night.
The only people who find it arrogant are ones who do not understand air conditioning is cheaper than heating and that water can be moved in aqueducts.
Nobody claims that Chicago should not exist, nor Minneapolis, nor New York. The only difference is that they depend on older heating methods instead of air conditioning.
This is true, but in the exact opposite sense you intend it.