Hacker News Reader

While trying to weasel info about the Google offer:

CHARLIE ROSE: So therefore, why did you choose to eliminate a Google-like proposition and incline yourself toward other propositions?

ANDREW MASON: It has to do with whether or not I would beat my wife.

View on HN

To be fair this makes sense in context...sort of. He is dodging an answer and he does so more articulately a few moments later.

Also - reading through the transcript this is possibly the most serious he's ever been in an interview. He actually talked about facts, answered questions, etc. instead of running on about how he likes to build doll houses.

I meant that Charlie Rose was trying to weasel information out of him, not that Andrew was weaseling away from the question.

Interesting - I have heard other people use the "have you stopped beating your wife?" question as their false-dichotomy example, but didn't realise it was in wide enough use that Andrew could use it with many people realising what he was meaning. But very clever...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com