Hacker News Reader

Comment by OedipusRex | Hacker News Reader

How did Google get in charge of this? Why did they get to set the price points for registering these domains? ICANN really sold out for this one.

View on HN

A couple years ago ICANN started letting companies buy customized TLDs through an auction process. I'm not sure how much they paid, but for comparison, Google tried buying .blog a while ago but was outbid by Automattic, who paid $19 million. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11686086

This is privatization of the web.

It's not. You can make your own DNS server and sell records to anyone you want. You just have to convince users to type in your address instead of 8.8.8.8.

Realistically, how could a project be setup around this?

I mean, how do we get everyday normal people to use it?

Its been attempted before (namecoin etc)...but maybe some advantage could be given to make it more attractive.

The current state of things are OK enough that it's not worth it to normal people to make the switch. If that time ever comes, people will do so.

You can see all the ICANN auction results here [1]:

• Google paid $25 million for “.app” [1]

• Amazon paid ~$5 million for “.buy”

• Amazon paid $2.2 million for “.spot”

• Verisign paid $135 million for “.web”

• Automattic paid $19 million for “.blog”

• ICM paid $3 million for “.sex”

[1] https://gtldresult.icann.org/application-result/applications...

[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/google-just-paid-25-million-...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com